Stephan James Leaves It All in the Ring | FEATURE Interview

Stephan James plays Carl Weathers in I Play Rocky. He talks about hearing no, the roles that take something out of him, the state of the industry and what he and his brother are building for Black Canadian artists.


“My mom, in an effort to keep us all inside and safe, would collect movies for us,” Stephan James says.

He was 11 or 12, right before high school, when he and his cousins were digging through the big box of VHS tapes she’d built up. One of his cousins pulled out Rocky. “He was like, ‘Yo, we should watch that. Trust me,'” James remembers. “I was like, OK, I don’t know. Let’s check it out.”

They put it in. “I just remember being glued to the screen for like two hours, thinking, this is the craziest,” he says. “I just felt so inspired, and like I wanted to do something.” They were so excited that they may have watched Rocky II and III right after. “So I do remember the first time I met the Italian Stallion.”

Fifty years after Rocky, he’s part of the franchise. In Peter Farrelly’s I Play Rocky, about how an unknown Sylvester Stallone (Anthony Ippolito) got the film made, James plays Carl Weathers, the actor who became Apollo Creed.

“Amazing, humbled, grateful,” he says of stepping into Weathers’ shoes. “It’s not lost on me that this is probably one of the single most important films in cinema history. Just what it means, the amount of people it’s inspired, and what it still means to people today, 50 years later. I’m honored and humbled to be able to continue the legacy of these characters who were so crucial in putting this together.”

Asked what Weathers would think of his performance, James says he has no idea. “I would only hope that he was proud of it. That he felt like I did him justice. That he wasn’t a one-note character,” he says. He hoped to give Weathers some agency in the time he had on screen, and to show a side of him people haven’t seen. “We’re so used to seeing him as Apollo Creed,” he says. “The special thing about this film is the humanity behind these characters. How unbelievable their own personal stories and journeys are, and how they all had to come together at once to pull this thing off.”

This isn’t the first time James has played a real person. He was John Lewis in Selma and Jesse Owens in Race. The research is similar to building any character, he says, but there’s a responsibility that comes with playing someone who existed, especially someone who is still alive.

On Selma, Lewis came to the set. “It’s one thing if I don’t have to look you in the face after this,” James says. “But I’m looking you in the face in real time.” He describes it as eerie. “You’ve been studying this person and staring at their face more than they know. Their legacies are so much bigger than them. You feel the weight of the world.”

Still, he says he’d rather carry that pressure himself. “I wouldn’t want that pressure to be on anyone else. I understand it, and I respect it,” he says. “I’ve already accepted that this is so much bigger than me. These aren’t just Black heroes or American heroes. They’re world heroes. They mean so much to the world. I just wanted to get out of my own way and give the best performance I possibly can.”

In 2022, James was announced to star in and produce a limited series about Jean-Michel Basquiat. He says the project has since been bought by another company, and it’s unclear whether it will get made. He’s still a big admirer of the artist. “Not that I need another real person to play, and the pressure of that,” he says. “I just love these people too much.”

James says he relates to the underdog story at the heart of Rocky. “You hear no way more times than you hear yes,” he says. “Every day you get tested, every week you get tested. Your own personal conviction gets tested, how much you believe in yourself.”

Does he ever want to flip the table?

“Oh, I flip the table and throw my hands up,” he says, laughing. “I still do.” But he has learned to hear a no differently. “No may just be a redirection into something better. Something more suited for you. Something that’s yours, that no one else can take away from you.”

Years ago, James auditioned for J.J. Abrams’ Star Wars. “Star Wars was that to me,” he says. “I was very much ready for it and very much manifesting this thing.” He went far in the process, but the role of Finn went to John Boyega.

Taking Star Wars meant Boyega had to step away from another film he was attached to, the Jesse Owens biopic Race. “Because he left that film, all of a sudden there’s the role of Jesse Owens that opened up,” James says, “and it fell in my lap.”

“Sometimes when it’s not yours, you have to be OK with that, because that just may mean that something else is right around the corner,” he says. “Am I gonna be upset sometimes when it doesn’t fall my way? Yeah, I’m a human being. But I’ve come to a place where I realize that sometimes it has to happen that way.”

He says the same about Lanterns, HBO’s Green Lantern series, where he was a finalist for John Stewart. “I’m very content. I’m here now. I’m talking to you. I’m vibing,” he says. “I don’t know that I would’ve been able to play Carl Weathers if I’d been working on that job.”

A lot of James’ roles are heavy ones, from Fonny in If Beale Street Could Talk to Rayshawn in #FreeRayshawn, men up against systems stacked against them.

Asked whether those roles come at a cost, he takes a few seconds before he answers.

“Maybe, yeah. I think we all make sacrifices in this business, and I think if you’re not leaving a piece of yourself on the table, then you’re not doing your job,” he says. “So yeah, there’s always a cost. But when something’s important enough or speaks to you enough, it’s worth the bill.”

What helps him reset after a project? “Nothing other than hearing from the audience that it sparked something in them and made them feel some type of way,” he says. “That it made them think something they never thought before. That’s it.”

When it comes to criticism, he leans on a simple idea: actors are about 30 percent of the process. A lot happens before they’re hired and after they leave set, from the edit to the music. “I don’t know what the editor is gonna do,” he says. “They might cut all my scenes from the movie. I don’t know. So I have to just be content with what I did on the day.”

“I give everything I can to my job,” he says. “I lay it all on the floor. I leave it all in the ring. And once the bell rings, that’s it. My hands are up.”

When he sees a bad comment on Twitter, he says, he tries to squint really hard and blur past it. He admits artists are sensitive, but the work is subjective. “You gotta put on your big-boy pants and realize not everything you do is gonna be for everybody,” he says. “It’s nice to hear people say sweet things about the work, but you can’t make that the only marker. Your fulfillment has to come from the itch you scratch, that you got to breathe life into this human being.”

Coming up in Toronto, James says, there weren’t many actors who looked like him that he could be directly inspired by.

“If I thought about my inspirations, it would have been Denzel and Will Smith,” he says. “But nobody who came from where I came from.” He also didn’t have anyone to go to for advice who had taken acting as far as he wanted to take it.

As his career grew, he realized he might be becoming that person for someone else.

“There may be some 12-year-old kid looking at me and my work,” he says, “being like, dang, look at him.”

He doesn’t want to call it a responsibility. “I just feel like, why not?” he says. “It doesn’t take anything away from me to use whatever platform I have to lift someone else up. There may be a lack of opportunity, but there’s no lack of excellence and greatness. So where can I find those pockets of excellence and greatness and help somebody step into their own destiny?”

That’s the idea behind The Black Academy, which James co-founded with his older brother, actor Shamier Anderson. Its flagship event, the Legacy Awards, airs on CBC. The academy also runs a Skills Development Program that gives underserved artists paid work on its productions, mainly the Legacy Awards, in areas like hair, makeup, sound and video editing.

James says he often shows up to interviews and has someone behind the camera tell him he gave them an opportunity a couple of years ago, and that it’s the reason they’re there today.

“That stuff blows me away,” he says. “That I could take the little platform I have and help start their career. It’s kind of unreal, the butterfly effect.”

The brothers also run Bay Mills Studios, their production company. They’ve always been close. Growing up, Anderson stayed “five steps down the hall,” so, James jokes, he couldn’t really avoid him. He says that shorthand has been invaluable in business. “He knows what I’m gonna say before I even say it.” Both are still going after acting jobs, and James says the competition keeps them sharp. As for who checks whose ego: “For the record, I’m checking his ego more,” he says, laughing.

He describes the two of them as very different, but aligned in their hearts and intentions. “I’m gonna take Train A and he’s gonna take Train B, but we’re both gonna get to the same platform at the end of the day.”

Directing is likely next, he says, when the timing works. He calls the actor-director relationship one of the most intimate he’s experienced on a film set, and he has been learning from the filmmakers he’s worked with. “In a nerdy way, I’ve just always been interested in cameras and lenses and shots,” he says. “I know my nerd brain is gonna take me there one day. It’s just about timing.”

James has been in the business for almost half his life, and he says it looks very different now than it did before COVID and before the strikes. When I mention that many people in the industry are talking about how little work there is, he agrees.

“There’s no question that there are fewer jobs,” he says, “and fewer jobs of high quality.”

There are plenty of projects out there, but not many that are well developed. I ask how that feels for someone who works on both sides, as an actor and as a producer.

“Not great,” he says. “In any industry where you’re seeing contraction, it’s gonna be scary or weird. Our business is no different. The things out there of value or of promise seem to be a little more few and far between.”

“It makes our decisions, the things we chase and pursue, that much more crucial,” he says. He turns down roles all the time, sometimes because he has already played a version of the character, sometimes because a good script just doesn’t speak to him. The slowdown also means he and the people who work on his behalf have to be more competitive. “Which is not a bad thing,” he says.

Bay Mills, he says, is a way for him and his brother to control their own narrative, though that means hearing no as producers too. “Not everything I pitch and try to create is gonna work,” he says. “But I am trying, and I am putting in the effort to create more interesting opportunities for all kinds of creators.”

If anything, he says, it makes him excited to be part of the change. “You understand just how much more rare it is nowadays to find a film that everyone seems to love and have a good feeling about.”

He also sees an opportunity in it. “Because everyone is feeling that lack of quality, it does stand out when you have something that is quality,” he says. “If you make something great, it’s gonna have maybe a better opportunity to be seen and be celebrated than it’s had in maybe a decade.”

I tell him that a lot of people are tired of remakes, but that I Play Rocky feels completely fresh. He agrees, “a hundred percent,” and connects it back to the film.

“Maybe the timing is such,” he says, “that 50 years later, we’re giving people a feeling they haven’t felt in almost 50 years.”


A mother in Scarborough once filled a box with tapes so her children could stay inside long enough to dream. Now grown, Stephan James is still building rooms: on sets, on crews, on a stage where Black Canadian artists get their flowers. Rooms where somebody else’s child can do more than dream.

The bell rings. He leaves it all in the ring. His hands go up.

Somewhere, a 12-year-old is watching.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *