What happens when one of literature’s most iconic sidekicks takes center stage? CBS’s Watson, starring Morris Chestnut, offers a bold reimagining of Dr. John Watson, blending medical mysteries with Sherlock Holmes lore in a way that is both ambitious and unconventional. Premiering January 26, 2025, following the AFC Championship game, Watson delivers a unique twist on familiar genres, but its execution isn’t without its challenges.
Set six months after the death of Sherlock Holmes, Watson opens with the titular doctor grappling with the trauma of losing his closest confidant and the physical toll of a traumatic brain injury (TBI). Fulfilling Sherlock’s last wishes, Watson relocates to Pittsburgh to open the Holmes Clinic, a facility dedicated to diagnosing and treating rare medical conditions. Despite this new chapter, Watson cannot fully escape his past as Moriarty’s shadow continues to loom large.
Morris Chestnut delivers a layered performance as Dr. Watson, balancing brilliance, vulnerability, and determination. His portrayal feels distinct from his previous roles as a doctor in Rosewood and The Resident, offering a fresh take on a character that audiences might otherwise compare to his past work.
Joining Chestnut is a talented ensemble cast that brings depth and intrigue to the series. Rochelle Aytes shines as Dr. Mary Morstan, Watson’s ex-wife and the hospital’s Medical Director, whose chemistry with Chestnut adds emotional weight to the narrative. Peter Mark Kendall portrays twin surgeons with clashing personalities—Stephens, the stoic perfectionist, and Adam, the charismatic but troubled sibling.
Eve Harlow stands out as Dr. Ingrid Derian, Watson’s neurologist and clear favorite, whose calculating demeanor hints at deeper complexities and darker pasts. Inga Schlingmann delivers a grounded performance as Dr. Sasha Lubbock, whose Southern charm contrasts with the clinic’s intense environment. Ritchie Coster rounds out the cast as Shinwell Johnson, Watson’s driver-turned-confidant, whose criminal past adds an air of mystery and level of distrust from the viewer.
Where Watson truly excels is in its approach to medical mysteries. While the show’s nods to Sherlock Holmes lore often feel forced, the medical cases are compelling and offer a fresh perspective within a crowded genre.
By focusing on rare and complex disorders, Watson sets itself apart from other medical dramas. It challenges viewers to think beyond traditional medical crises, offering a deeper commentary on the healthcare system and the human stories behind these conditions.
While Watson’s connection to Sherlock Holmes is a key selling point, it often becomes a hindrance. References like Watson’s frequent use of “Eureka!” or Shinwell Johnson’s ties to Scotland Yard feel out of place in the show’s modern Pittsburgh setting. These callbacks can distract from the series’ stronger focus on medical mysteries and character development.
Watson is a slow burn, which may test the patience of viewers accustomed to fast-paced dramas. However, this deliberate pacing allows for richer character development and more thoughtful storytelling. Each member of the ensemble cast is given room to grow, and their backstories unfold gradually, adding layers to the narrative.
For those willing to invest, Watson offers a unique viewing experience that rewards attention to detail. The tension between Watson and Mary, the mystery surrounding the clinic’s staff, and the ethical dilemmas posed by the medical cases all contribute to a narrative that builds steadily over time.
Though Watson stumbles in its early episodes, it gradually carves out a distinct identity as a nuanced blend of medical drama and detective mystery. Morris Chestnut’s charisma and the intriguing ensemble cast give the show a solid foundation, even as it struggles to balance its Sherlockian roots with its modern-day setting.
Ultimately, Watson is not an instant hit, but it holds promise. For viewers who appreciate slow-burn storytelling, nuanced characters, and fresh takes on medical dramas, Watson is worth watching. Approach it with fresh eyes, and you may find yourself drawn into this unique reimagining of a classic character.